Pluto and Ancient Sanskrit Texts
Some modern astrologers claim Pluto was mentioned in the Mahabharata, using lines from the Bhishma Parva. The famous verses—
“Krittikaam Peedayan Teekshnaihi Nakshatram” and “Krittikasu Grahasteevro Nakshatre Prathame Jvalan”
Describe a strong, slow-moving celestial body affecting the Krittika constellation. These lines are not direct proof but show that ancient writers were keen observers of the sky.
Is Pluto Really in the Mahabharata?
The verses talk about a “sharp” or “intense” object in the sky, troubling the Pleiades (Krittika).
Some people say this could be Pluto, as it moves slowly and takes years to cross one zodiac sign.
But Mahabharata does not use the name "Pluto" or give clear details for distant planets.
Most traditional scholars say these lines simply describe common planets or a poetic event, not Pluto.
Why Is Pluto Missing from Navagraha?
Vedic astrology’s Navagraha group has only the Sun, Moon, Mercury, Venus, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Rahu, and Ketu. Pluto is missing because:
-
Ancient Indian astronomers picked planets they could see with their eyes. No telescope, no Pluto.
-
Pluto is so far away and moves so slowly, it’s not useful for daily predictions or rituals.
-
It doesn’t show up clearly in ancient texts or have any proven role in calendars or seasons.
What Do Classic Texts and Experts Say?
Classic books like the Purana and Mahabharata talk about planets, but always those visible without tools.
The Navagraha were chosen for astrology because they had a clear, practical effect on life and time.
Leading experts like Dr. B.V. Raman and other Vedic astrologers reject Pluto as an astrological planet, since there’s no strong, old proof in texts and daily practice.
The Modern View and Its Limits
Some people today try to match mysterious lines from old texts with new discoveries. They use Pluto’s movement and place in the sky to support their claims.
But most astrologers and historians say these are just guesses—not scientific or scriptural evidence.
Pluto in Vedic Astrology—Fact or Fiction?
Pluto might be interesting for thinkers and modern astrologers, but it isn’t part of ancient Vedic astrology.
Indian astrology focused on planets that could be seen and tracked. Pluto’s late discovery and lack of clear mention in classic texts kept it out of the Navagraha system.
For detailed astrological advice, the wisdom of visible planets still rules in Vedic tradition.
